Many thanks to Phil Taylor for directing me to this article in the Sunday Times eight days ago.
Here is an extract:
The analysis of figures in 14 European countries found that Britain has by far the highest proportion of single mothers in the European Union.The report says that in 2001, more than 8% of British households were headed by a single mother aged 18-35, while the UK also has one of the highest rates of benefits for single mothers.
In 1994 a single mother with two children who worked for about 18 hours a week could expect more than £2,000 a year in benefits. By 2001 the figure had increased to more than £3,500.
The researchers do not say outright that high benefits accelerate family break-up. Others, however, believe the study shows that generous benefits for single motherhood provide an incentive for women to have children alone.
Frank Field,
the former Labour minister for social security, said: “I’ve always believed in a causal link between benefits and the number of single mothers.“We’ve got to change so that people don’t become single mothers. For some, they become single mothers by accident, while for others it’s a deliberate choice.”
The study contrasts the situation in Britain and elsewhere in northern Europe with Mediterranean countries such as Spain, where single-mother families constitute less than 1% of the total. Spanish single mothers received £137 in special benefits a year in 1994, which by 2001 had declined to £38.
Spain, along with Greece, Portugal and Italy, have the lowest numbers of single-mother families in Europe.
Latest figures from the Office for National Statistics show single-mother families in Britain have steadily risen from 1% of all households with children in 1971 to 11% in 2004.
Libertad Gonzalez, a Barcelona academic who compiled the research, studied a sample of 6,580 single mothers from the European Community Household Panel. She estimates that for every £675 a state offers in benefits to lone parents, the incidence of single mothers goes up in that country by 2%.
After Britain, Ireland — despite its Catholic heritage — has the highest proportion of single mothers in the EU. In 2001 more than 4% of households were headed by single mothers. Irish lone mothers receive as much in benefits as their British counterparts.
Gonzalez said single mothers received more benefits in Britain and Ireland because they had “liberal” social policies where welfare payments were means-tested, which gave greater assistance to the greatest in need.
By contrast the southern European countries had benefits systems where there was an implicit understanding that family networks should provide assistance.
“The correlation across countries is quite striking,” said Gonzalez. “The countries with the highest incidence of single mothers are also the countries with more generous benefit, and vice versa . . . Spain, Greece and Portugal with small numbers of single mothers also have lower benefit levels. The UK and Ireland are both generous with benefits and have a higher incidence of these families.
See also this previous entry citing Libertad Gonzalez.
Posted by James Bartholomew • Indexed in Housing • Parenting • Welfare benefits
Comments (7)
TrackBack (11)
Comments
Frank Field really shouldn't be in the Labour Party. He speaks far too much common sense.
Posted by: Raw Carrot at September 11, 2006 05:03 PM
'tis a disgrace what has happened; but hte Tories were pilloried when they tried to reduce benefits.
Attacking the poor in society is not a vote winner.
We need better ideas for supporting families, familay life, staying at school and sex education. This is all progressive and will allow then the reduction in welfare spending.
I'd cut benefits tomorrow but then no one votes for me!
Posted by: cityunslicker at September 13, 2006 11:13 AM
Hi, I'm visiting your site for the first time after Iain's recommendation on his Top Tory list just published. I'm interested in lots of the topics you cover, they are the same areas that I cover too, so I will be visiting again.
Posted by: Ellee at September 16, 2006 09:11 PM
Off topic from this post, but I've been looking unsuccessfully for an email address to send along some thoughts, and a suggestion, regarding your wonderful column on home education in last week's Spectator.
We're a home educating family in western Canada, and much in your article resonated with me, with our own reasons for pulling our eldest from the local public (state) school several years ago when she was six.
As far as the "narrative sweep", I would suggest Sir Ernst Gombrich's "Little History of the World", which is slim but elegant and definitely sweeping. It's also available unabridged on audio
CD, which my children (ages 9, 7, and 5.5) enjoying listening to at bedtime, and for something different you can find it too
Ernst-Gombrich/dp/2850257044/sr=1-3/qid=1158970220/ref=sr_1_3/171-0413899-3395421?ie=UTF8&s=books">en francais, which might work well with the French studies.
All best wishes to you and your family on your new adventures, academic and otherwise.
Posted by: Becky at September 23, 2006 07:19 PM
Well, one reason for UK to have more single mothers than other European country, is that here, there is a chance to survive, with a little help from the Estate. The white European woman from Europe, stop having children, no one at all. As to have a child, with a huge posible chance of ending as a single parent, anyway, and the current situation of this rather negative against mothers, and their children, because money being the issue rather than a female fact, rather than a man one, has lead society to this situation of denial of the natural aspect of reproduction as to say next generation of human beings, onto the shoulder of woman, as always. So the inmigration society, have been the ones reproducing, inside Europe, because of this, wich will have a repercusion in the near future, as is happening in countries as Spain at the moment.
We all come from mothers, and know that is a false staitment, as it was in the past, to say that to stay at home, and do all the requierements for the children to be attended, is not a job.
i am sure we all heard, our mothers complaint about this, lack of respect to the excellent job they can do on the service of the familly.
It is sad, to think that all UK mothers, have been just leaving from the UK tax payers, for staying at home doing NO WORK.
It is an insult, and an abuse, so you say the children will be better off, on care of strangers, and arriving at home, to an empty house, ...and I ask, is the goverment go to punish one more generation, with economical issues?
Education fail, economy fail, job wages fail, care sistem for single mums alredy fail, jobs for profesionals fail, contracts fail, health centers fail, unemployment rise....
Are these conditions, the right ones for finding a well payed job? or instead, does the goverment think they have the right to force me to work for free, in anything bellow my degree? because I am a single mother?
Absurd. And to all the criticism to single mothers, just remember your mum, and be honest, if she did stayed at home, she did not work?
and if she did work out from the house....did she had time for you?
just honest...that is all.
Posted by: Caballero de Arucas. at December 12, 2008 06:47 AM
Stop it in the next generation & carry on benefits for those already ion the system. This will stop another generation of losers being like Caballero (above poster).
If YOU want kids YOU pay for them! No-one pays for my lifestyle choices besides me!
Posted by: Bowers at July 28, 2009 10:06 PM
Warning: file(http://63.247.138.2/~bartholo/randomquotes.dump) [function.file]: failed to open stream: No route to host in /home/bartholo/public_html/archives/2006/09/britain_has_the.php on line 366
Warning: implode() [function.implode]: Invalid arguments passed in /home/bartholo/public_html/archives/2006/09/britain_has_the.php on line 366
It was instructive to listen to Stephen Nolan on the BBC (standing in for Victoria Derbyshire) this morning, pre the PM's speech about 'social exclusion'. Nolan, a simple-minded Ulsterman who drips with the fat of his own ego and wallows in righteous ersatz fairness, was very keen to predict how Blair might 'help' single mothers. I think he meant, by giving them bigger flats. And more money. And possibly state-sponsored people carriers.
Posted by: thenorthernsoulboy at September 5, 2006 12:23 PM